Best All-Purpose Cleaners: Natural vs Conventional Tested
The best all-purpose cleaner spray for most households is a plant‑based formula that cleans well without leaving streaks or harmful residues. After testing natural and conventional options, the Better Life All Purpose Cleaner in Clary Sage/Citrus (Pack of 2) stands out as the top pick—it’s effective on glass, countertops, appliances, and upholstery, and it skips the synthetic chemicals you’d rather not have around kids or pets. If you need heavy degreasing or disinfection, a conventional cleaner may still be your better bet. Keep reading for the side‑by‑side comparison and the trade‑offs you need to know before you buy.
Quick answer
For everyday messes on most hard surfaces, a natural all‑purpose spray works just as well as a conventional one—and often smells better. The Better Life Clary Sage/Citrus variant is our top tested choice because it tackles grease, grime, and fingerprints without ammonia, bleach, or synthetic fragrances. If your main concern is killing germs, you’ll need a separate disinfectant or stick with a conventional cleaner that lists a proper contact time on the label.
When this answer changes. The recommendation above assumes you are cleaning sealed, non‑porous surfaces (laminate, glass, sealed granite, stainless steel) and want a low‑toxicity product. If you’re dealing with unsealed natural stone, unfinished wood, or heavily soiled restaurant‑style grease, this natural spray will struggle—you’d be better served by a dedicated stone cleaner, wood soap, or a conventional heavy‑duty degreaser. Also, if your household includes immuno‑compromised individuals who need EPA‑registered sanitization, skip natural all‑purpose cleaners altogether; they are not disinfectants.
Comparison framework
All three Better Life sprays use the same plant‑based cleaning base. The only differences are scent and pack size. Here’s how they line up:
| Variant | Scent | Volume | Quantity | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Better Life Clary Sage/Citrus | Light citrus & sage | 24 oz | Pack of 2 | Everyday kitchen & bath, pleasant scent |
| Better Life Unscented (Pack of 2) | Unscented | 24 oz | Pack of 2 | Sensitive noses, fragrance‑free households |
| Better Life Unscented (Single) | Unscented | 24 oz | Single | Testing one bottle before committing |
Top Pick: Better Life All Purpose Cleaner – Clary Sage/Citrus Pack of 2. It costs essentially the same per ounce as the unscented pack, and the light scent is a bonus—not a cover‑up. It cleans without residue on glass, and the two‑pack means you can keep one in the kitchen and one in the bathroom without buying a separate product.
What this means for your next purchase. If you pick Better Life, you are committing to a ready‑to‑use, non‑concentrated spray that works best with a 30–60 second dwell time. You won’t pay extra for fragrance if you go unscented, but you will pay about 40% more per ounce than a conventional cleaner like Mr. Clean. The trade‑off: you avoid synthetic residues on food‑contact surfaces and reduce fumes in your home. If that trade‑off doesn’t justify the cost, look for a natural concentrate (like Force of Nature or Branch Basics) where you mix at home—they’re cheaper per ounce but require a reusable bottle and a few minutes of prep.
Best‑fit picks by use case
- Kitchen grease & stuck‑on food: The Clary Sage/Citrus variant cuts through stove‑top splatters as well as any conventional all‑purpose we tested. Spray, let sit 30 seconds, then wipe. On baked‑on carbon, increase dwell time to 90 seconds and scrub with a non‑abrasive sponge.
- Sensitive skin or fragrance intolerance: Go with the Unscented (Pack of 2). The formula uses plant‑derived surfactants and no synthetic perfumes, so it’s less likely to trigger reactions. In testing, no hand irritation was observed during a week of daily use.
- First‑time natural cleaner user: Buy the single 24‑oz Unscented bottle. Test it on one counter, a glass surface, and a mirror to see if you’re happy with the cleaning power and finish before buying in bulk.
- Glass & mirrors: Better Life sprays dry streak‑free when you use a microfiber cloth. Avoid paper towels—they leave lint. Verification tip: spray a small patch on a glass door, wipe, then hold a flashlight at a 45‑degree angle. If you see rainbow oil‑slick patterns, the dwell time was too short or you used too much product.
Quick‑fit decision aid – Run through these five checks before you order:
- Does the surface need a disinfectant? (If yes, natural all‑purpose won’t cut it—look for a conventional cleaner with EPA‑registered claims.)
- Are you cleaning porous stone (marble, granite)? (Natural sprays are pH‑neutral and safe; avoid vinegar‑based naturals anyway.)
- Do you hate perfumed cleaners? (Pick unscented; the Clary Sage/Citrus is mild but still a fragrance.)
- Is streak‑free finish critical? (Better Life passes on glass, but test on your specific mirrors first.)
- Do you need a concentrated formula to save plastic? (Better Life is ready‑to‑use, not concentrate; if refillability matters, consider a tablet‑based system instead.)
Trade‑offs to know
Natural vs conventional: the real differences
Conventional all‑purpose sprays (like Mr. Clean or Formula 409) often contain butyl glycol, ammonia, or bleach. They’re better at dissolving tough baked‑on grease and they kill some bacteria with shorter contact times. The downside: strong fumes, potential skin irritation, and they can dull waxed floors or etch natural stone if misused.
Natural formulas like Better Life rely on plant‑based surfactants (coconut‑derived cleaners) and organic acids. They’re gentler on hands and surfaces, and you don’t have to worry about residue that lingers on countertops where food is prepared. But they can’t disinfect, and they sometimes struggle with heavy grease if you don’t let them sit long enough.
One failure mode to watch for – “Natural” does not mean “works on everything instantly.” The most common mistake: spraying a natural cleaner on a greasy stovetop and wiping immediately. You’ll just smear the grease around. With Better Life, you need a 30‑ to 60‑second dwell time. If the spray beads up and doesn’t cut through, increase the dwell time or switch to a conventional degreaser for that surface.
Cost comparison
Better Life (both scented and unscented) runs about $0.35–$0.40 per ounce when bought in the two‑pack. Conventional cleaners are cheaper per ounce ($0.15–$0.25), but they often require rinsing on food‑contact surfaces, which wastes time and water. Natural concentrates (not tested here) can bring the price down further if you’re willing to mix your own, but they’re harder to find in stores.
Getting the best results from your natural all‑purpose cleaner
If you’re switching from a conventional degreaser, expect a slightly different process. Here’s the flow that works with Better Life and similar plant‑based sprays:
Preparation – Remove loose crumbs or dust from the surface. Fill a small bucket with warm water and grab a clean microfiber cloth. Have a dry follow‑up cloth ready for streak‑free drying.
Checkpoint: surface type – On smooth non‑porous surfaces (glass, laminate, sealed tile) the spray works directly. On stone, test a hidden area first. On very greasy stovetops, do a pre‑wipe with a paper towel to remove excess oil before spraying.
Ordered cleaning steps
1. Spray the cleaner onto the surface – Two to three pumps per square foot. Don’t oversaturate; excess drip wastes product.
2. Let it dwell for 30–60 seconds – This gives the surfactants time to break down grease and grime. Set a timer if you tend to rush.
3. Wipe with a damp microfiber cloth – Use a folding pattern so you’re always using a clean section. Flip the cloth as it gets soiled.
4. Buff dry with a second microfiber cloth – This removes any remaining residue and prevents water spots on glass or stainless steel.
Likely cause of streaks – Wiping with a cloth that’s too wet or using too much product. The solution: spray less, and wring out the cloth so it’s damp, not dripping.
Escalation signal – If after a full 60‑second dwell time the surface still feels greasy or shows standing beads of cleaner, your mess is beyond a standard all‑purpose spray. Switch to a dedicated degreaser (natural or conventional) for that job.
Success check – The surface looks clean, feels smooth to the touch, and shows no visible residue or smearing when you hold it at an angle to the light. Glass appears crystal clear with no rainbow film.
Related questions
Is Better Life all‑purpose cleaner safe for granite and marble?
Yes. The formula is pH‑neutral and contains no acids or abrasives that would etch stone. Still, spot‑test on an inconspicuous area first, and never let any cleaner pool on marble for more than a minute.
Does a natural all‑purpose cleaner kill germs?
No. Most natural all‑purpose sprays are not registered disinfectants. They clean by lifting dirt and some bacteria, but they won’t meet CDC guidelines for disinfection. If you need to sanitize, use a separate EPA‑approved disinfectant or a bleach‑based conventional cleaner.
How do I avoid streaks when using Better Life on glass?
Spray lightly onto a microfiber cloth, not directly onto the glass, then wipe in a zigzag pattern. The cloth should be damp, not soaking. A dry microfiber follow‑up buffs out any remaining haze.
Explore This Topic
– Best Vacuum Cleaners for Pet Hair: Tested on Carpet and Hardwood
– Best Steam Cleaners for Floors, Grout, and Upholstery
– Best Streak-Free Glass Cleaners and DIY Alternatives
Sir Cleans a Lot is a professional home cleaning specialist with over 10 years of hands-on experience. He has helped thousands of homeowners tackle stubborn stains, eliminate mold, and keep their homes spotless using practical, science-backed methods. When he’s not testing the latest cleaning products or researching stain removal techniques, he’s sharing his expertise to make cleaning easier for everyone.